EXCLUSIVE: Kevin Costner's Legal Battle Erupts — Radar Lifts the Lid on the Explosive 'Harassment' Lawsuit Filed by Ex-stuntwoman Over 'Violent and Unscripted' Rape Scene in His Flop Western Film
Kevin Costner's legal battle erupts after an ex-stuntwoman filed a harassment lawsuit over an unscripted rape scene.
Sept. 18 2025, Published 6:15 a.m. ET
For more than 30 years, Kevin Costner has been toiling on Horizon: An American Saga, an epic film series about the American West, RadarOnline.com can reveal.
His goal, he explained on August 18, has been to address themes "relevant to that time period, including the impact of the American Civil War, the relationship between settlers and Native Americans, the challenges faced by European immigrants seeking a better life, and the foundational role played by women of the time" including "the violence and difficult conditions they faced."
Inside The Complaint
Devyn LaBella alleged she suffered permanent trauma from an unscripted scene during 'Horizon.'
But according to a stand-in on the second movie in his Horizon series, that vision has been deeply compromised.
In May, stuntwoman Devyn LaBella filed suit against the actor and the saga's production companies, claiming she was "the victim of a violent, unscripted, unscheduled rape scene" directed by the Oscar winner for the second of four planned Horizon movies while serving as a double for actress Ella Hunt in 2023.
In her sexual harassment and hostile workplace environment complaint, LaBella, who's seeking unspecified damages, alleges she was left with "permanent trauma" she'll have to "address for years to come."
The May 2 filing took place just one day after Costner was blindsided by divorce papers from second wife, Christine Baumgartner.
Marty Singer, the 70-year-old star's lawyer, initially called the suit a "shakedown."
Now, Costner has gone further, branding LaBella's claims a "bold-faced lie" in his own court filing.
"My belief is that Devyn's claims were designed, through the use of false statements and sensationalistic language, to damage my reputation," the Hollywood legend wrote in a lengthy declaration, calling the claims against him "absolutely false."
He alleged LaBella wants to "embarrass" him and hurt the Horizon movies "in order to gain a massive and unjustified payday."
Costner's Nightmare
In his court filing, Kevin Costner called LaBella's lawsuit a 'bold-faced lie' and asked a judge to dismiss it.
Moreover, having to read about and address her allegations "involving the words 'rape' and 'assault,'" Kevin added, "has been an absolute nightmare."
A source told RadarOnline.com the Dances With Wolves star "is fighting these heinous claims with everything he's got," adding that the three-time Golden Globe winner "has said from the start that it's a classic stick-up lawsuit that has zero merit whatsoever."
His lawyer has asked a judge to dismiss LaBella's suit at a hearing.
According to LaBella, Kevin improvised a scene in which an actor aggressively raked up her skirt and straddled her.
In June, she amended her lawsuit to include text messages she exchanged with the film's intimacy coordinator, Celeste Chaney, a day after the shot was blocked in which she described it as an "abomination" and listed questions about how it was handled before asking, "Who is gonna take responsibility for the abuse of power, negligence and ignorance on set?"
The intimacy coordinator, who wasn't present during the alleged incident, has backed LaBella, calling the shot a "violent rape scene" that "was unexpectedly sprung on the actors and stunt professionals," also noting LaBella"did not have the appropriate modesty garments to ensure adequate coverage, safety or protection."
Costner maintained that's not what happened. He said LaBella's "privacy was fully maintained" – which was confirmed in explosive photos of her and others taken on set that day that he submitted with his filing – during the moments in question.
Costner's legal team submitted crew testimony disputing LaBella's account of the scene.
In a special motion to strike LaBella's complaint, Costner's attorney stated LaBella "was laughing and smiling during the blocking of the shot," which Costner clarified was rehearsed but never filmed, and was only "a buildup and foretelling" of a rape that occurs offscreen and not itself a simulated rape.
According to the director, it involved "the simple act of moving the hem of the dress from the ankle to the knee" and an actor swinging his leg over her and ending up "on all fours" to create "a moment of absolute clarity for the audience to absorb what would happen offscreen."
In addition to his own account, Costner's legal team submitted a gushing text LaBella sent to her supervisor nine days later, thanking him for "these wonderful weeks" as well as "the sworn testimony of a dozen respected, veteran film crew members with personal knowledge of the facts at issue."
Support For Costner
Stunt coordinator Wade Allen and actor Roger Ivens both denied a simulated rape was performed.
Two of those have surfaced publicly and support Costner's version of events. Wade Allen, the stunt coordinator who hired and supervised LaBella and was there during shot blocking, insisted that "at no point that day did she evidence any distress or discomfort, or any concern about what she had been asked to do," per Variety, adding that LaBella gave him a thumbs-up before and after the run-through of the scene he said involved "no intimacy, no nudity, no sexual conduct or sexual movement of any kind."
The other performer in the shot, actor Roger Ivens, also challenged what he called a "false and sensationalist" description of their scene as depicting a violent rape.
"It is not what happened," Ivens said. "This was not in any way, shape, or form a simulated sex scene."
"The truth matters," Costnert wrote in his declaration, which is why, "even at the high cost of this lawsuit" – both "financial and personal," he clarified – "I will always speak up to defend myself and my crew against false allegations."
LaBella's attorney accused Kevin Costner of trying to avoid accountability.
He also countered LaBella's claim she suffered career consequences for speaking out and hasn't been hired by the stunt coordinator since May 2023.
It's "absurd," he said in his declaration, since filming on Horizon III hasn't started.
LaBella's attorney, James Vagnin, hit back at Costner, calling his account "continued evidence that one of Hollywood's most powerful men is trying to skirt accountability for reckless and harmful behavior."
According to LaBella's lawyer's statement: "Claims that Devyn's professional demeanor on set discredits the assault she endured is not only insulting to victims everywhere, but directly disproven by multiple eyewitness accounts and irrefutable evidence from the immediate aftermath of the incident, including phone calls, text messages and a scathing report from the production's intimacy coordinator. This baseless motion is nothing but a desperate delay tactic from a panicked legal team with no real defense."
The only things damaging Costner's reputation, Devyn's legal team added, "are his own reckless, harmful behavior and the offensive narrative he's spreading to cover it up."
Costner's Struggles
Never Miss an
Daily updates from the heart of Hollywood, right to your inbox
By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you’re agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Costner admitted 'Horizon: Chapter I' underperformed after earning just $38.7 million worldwide.
The legal drama isn't the only issue plaguing Costner's Horizon series.
He self-funded much of his passion project, investing at least $38 million and even mortgaging some of his property to help finance it.
After the first installment, which combined with the second had a reported budget of $100 million, made just $38.7 million at the worldwide box office last summer, the theatrical release of Chapter II was delayed – something Costner confessed last September "probably was a reaction" to Chapter I's underperformance.
However,"it didn't have overwhelming success."
With an estimated net worth of $250 million, the Bodyguard star "is still a very wealthy man," the source told RadarOnline.com.
"But he's been hit hard with some major financial setbacks in recent times." His contentious divorce from second wife Baumgartner, 51, the mother of his three youngest kids ended with a judge deciding in 2023 that their prenup would stand.
Yet Baumgartner hardly walked away empty-handed, receiving a $1.5 million lump sum and $63K a month in child support.
Costner's ex-wife Christine Baumgartner received a $1.5 million payout and $63K monthly child support after divorce.
"He's still sore about that to this day," added the source. "And sinking all that money into Horizon – only to see it struggle with audiences – was another hammer blow."
Horizon's setbacks, Costner insisted last year, have only made him want to forge ahead with the planned four-part epic.
"Sometimes when things don't come to us easily, we want to just step away. But there's something in me that only increases my desire when something is not working," he said, adding, "When I feel rejection, unlike anybody else, when I open my eyes from my disappointment, my desire is only increased."
