EXCLUSIVE: He Still Has to Put His Pants on in the Morning! Proof the Baseball-Loving First U.S. Pope in History Is Just an 'Average Joe'
The pontiff loves baseball.
June 2 2025, Published 6:30 a.m. ET
As beloved Pope Leo XIV takes the reins of the Roman Catholic Church – whose faithful number 1.4 billion – RadarOnline.com can reveal the untold story of the Chicago-born pontiff’s bizarre life in America.
Formerly known as Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, His Holiness has already made history by being elected as the 267th leader of the world’s Catholics following the fatal stroke of 88-year-old Pope Francis on April 21, because he’s the first-ever Bishop of Rome to come from the United States.
Though Pope Leo, 69, now offers blessings from the ornate balcony of St. Peter's Basilica at the Vatican, he was once a baseball-loving kid from the Windy City who dreamed of religious life.
Humble Life
John Prevost fondly recalled his younger brother 'playing priest' at their South Side Chicago home.
Early on, the Prevost family moved to the humble suburb of Dolton, Ill. But their Sundays included worshipping at St. Mary of the Assumption on Chicago's gritty South Side and cheering on the city’s White Sox.
But little Bob’s other hobbies were much different from those of his peers.
John Prevost, 71, said of his former altar boy brother: "Some people play school, some people play army, he played priest, and we had to go to Mass. The women down the street said he would be the first American pope."
However, John also reveals teenage Bob loved to get "behind the wheel."
Louis Prevost, 74, the oldest of Leo's two siblings, said his devout bro "always wanted to play priest."
Family Memories
Louis Prevost remembered how their mom turned an ironing board and crackers into little Robert's first altar and communion.
He joked: "I told my brother he was weird… Nobody else in our ’hood played priest, but Robert did. And our parents always supported his wishes in that area. Mom let him use our ironing board to put a sheet over (as a pretend altar), and crackers we had for communion. My brother enjoyed this."
Louis added in the second grade, a nun even told young Bob: "You will be pope some day."
Father Bill Lego, who was Leo's classmate at both St. Augustine Seminary High School and Villanova University, recalled the future pontiff showed "leadership ability," thoughtfulness – and a "sense of humor."
Leo spent a large chunk of his church career ministering in Peru, where he acquired a second citizenship. But in 1999, Leo came back home to lead Chicago's Augustinian order for over a decade.
Father Bill Lego, a seminary classmate, said Pope Leo's leadership and humor were evident even before his time ministering in Peru.
He was even caught on camera during the 2005 World Series as the Sox took on the Houston Astros in Game 1. Leo saw the Sox win on their way to a four-game sweep.
The Holy Father admits he's "quite the amateur tennis player," and John revealed his brother is also a fan of the games Wordle and Words With Friends.
"It's something to keep his mind off life in the real world," John explained.
Never Miss an
Daily updates from the heart of Hollywood, right to your inbox
By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you’re agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Villanova's Father Arthur Purcaro believes Leo's papal name marks a rebirth – but added with a smile.
By all accounts, Leo continues to root for the Sox, and Father Arthur Purcaro – now the assistant vice president of mission and ministry at Villanova – said his old pal still "loves deep-dish pizza."
Purcaro added: "I like the idea, the fact that when someone becomes pope, they change their name. He’s had a new birth. He's called to be more than he was."
But he also feels: "Bob will always be Bob."
