America's Got Talent Scrambling To Save Face Amid Stuttering Soldier Scandal

By Amber GoodhandRadar News Editor

America’s Got Talent is under some serious scrutiny for the singing and stuttering soldier, Timothy Poe, whose entire audition story is allegedly false — and insiders exclusively tell that the hit NBC show is scrambling to save their reputation.

When Poe’s audition aired earlier this week, hearts broke as he told the tale of a grenade going off while he was serving in the military in Afghanistan in 2009 and his subsequent brain injury that left him with a pronounced stutter.

PHOTOS: Behind The Scenes At American Idol

“Almost everything this guy told the show was a lie. But America’s Got Talent has their bases covered and didn’t do anything wrong,” the insider told

“The show can’t possibly check out the story of every individual that tries out. But they certainly don’t like to be lied to and execs are not at all happy that Tim has cast a negative notion on the family show.”

PHOTOS: American Idols! Our Favorite All-American Bikini Babes

According to the source, AGT has their legal team on top of the situation and they don’t appear to be at fault for anything.

“Doesn’t change the fact that they’re freaking out a little bit and scrambling to protect the show’s name,” the insider said.

PHOTOS: American Idol’s Most Memorable Contestants

“Timothy’s appearance was supposed to be a sob story to tug at people’s hearts and instead it’s turned into damage control for the show.”

Reports have surfaced — and even a statement from the military themselves! — denouncing most of what Poe claimed in his audition.

PHOTOS: American Idol 2009: Then and Now

“Sgt. Poe’s official military records do not indicate that he was injured by a grenade in combat while serving in Afghanistan in 2009, as he reports,” the Minnesota National Guard said in a released statement.

Poe also said in his audition that he realized he could sing only after his speech therapist suggested he practice singing in the show, but it turns out he was the lead singer of a band in Minnesota for four years called Crawl Space.

PHOTOS: American Idol Runner-Ups

And finally, the photo AGT flashed during Poe’s audition of a man in the field with military fatigues on, wasn’t even him!

“Timothy supplied that photo to America’s Got Talent claiming it was him,” the insider said.

PHOTOS: American Idol Winners

“Execs for the show want Timothy’s appearance forgotten, and I wouldn’t count on seeing him in Vegas or any of the future episodes.”


Howard Stern Tells Goth Opera Prodigy: ‘You Blew The Roof Off The Joint!’

6-Year-Old ‘Superstar’ Blows Away Judges On America’s Got Talent

Howard Stern Says ‘I Hate Glee’ On America’s Got Talent

Howard Stern Makes 7-Year-Old Cry On America’s Got Talent

blog comments powered by Disqus