American Idol: Who Might Be Gone In A Flash?
![//american idol](https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/480x251/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 480w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/640x335/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 640w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/768x402/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 768w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/1024x536/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 1024w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/1280x670/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 1280w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/1440x753/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 1440w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/1600x837/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 1600w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/RBac3gQ7L/2160x1130/2012/04/american-idol.jpg?position=top 2160w)
Apr. 4 2012, Published 5:00 a.m. ET
OK, so Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson weren’t that abrasive toward Hollie Cavanaugh, but her ill-received interpretation of Irene Cara’s Flashdance helped the normally-sugar sweet panel channel their inner-Simon Cowell.
Tyler told the McKinney, Texas native: "Your pitch was all over the place, I'm so sorry to tell you."
“You’re listening to what everyone is telling you,” a frustrated Randy Jackson explained to the 18-year-old. “It didn’t feel like the pop song it is.”
Elise Testone didn’t fare much better during the tribute to the decade of decadence, as her rendition of Foreigner’s ballad I Want to Know What Love Is had Jackson telling her she was "much better than” she showed.
"It was just out of tune everywhere for me," he told the 28-year-old South Carolina native.
On the flipside, Joshua Ledet and Jessica Sanchez simply killed it in their duet of Aretha Franklin and George Michael’s I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me), leading Jackson to proclaim the duet "one of the greatest performances" he’s seen in 11 years on the panel.
- BREAKING: Joe Biden Set To Withdraw From Race This Weekend – But Will NOT Endorse Kamala Harris, D.C. Insider Claims
- BOB NEWHART DEAD AT 94: Legendary Actor and Comedian Known for Stone-Faced Delivery Passed Away at Home
- Sad End: Shannen Doherty Received Salvador Dali Painting, Malibu Mansion and ‛Charmed’ Money in Day-Before-Death Split Settlement
“It was so over the top,” Tyler said, “it defies judging.”
Fun fact: After years of internal strife and personal problems, Tyler and Aerosmith sprung back into relevancy -- and had a hand in the first ever mainstream rap hit — collaborating with Run-D.M.C. on the 1986 remake of their hit, Walk This Way.
Watch the video on RadarOnline.com
Someone’s getting eliminated when American Idol’s 11th season continues Thursday at 8/7c on Fox.