This is a case of she said, she said! In the latest clip from I Am Cait, exes Caitlyn and Kris Jenner get dinner with the former Olympian's squad in New Orleans — but the conversation quickly turns sour.
When asked if Caitlyn told her about her transgender identity "early on" in their relationship, Kris answered flatly, "no."
"Oh I did too!" Caitlyn interjects.
"She keeps saying she told me but she didn't do it," Kris replies with some sass. "What happened was a conversation in a driveway, he says to me, 'Do you ever want to have more kids?' And I said, 'Oh God no.' So he says, 'Oh neither do I, that's like, that's great! And I couldn't have any more kids if I wanted to.'"
"And he goes, 'Oh jeez you know back in the '80s I messed around with this or that and it kind of screwed up my sperm count but whatever,'" she continues.
Kris explained that she assumed it might've been "steroids" because "he was an athlete."
"He never said it was estrogen, he never said anything, he just said, 'I took some s**t in the '80s,'" she told Cait's table of gals. "There was no, 'I am transgender.'"
Caitlyn was quick to defend her case, saying that she had told Kris she "had a condition that I've been dealing with forever" and "I was on hormones" which is why it "might be tough to get pregnant."
Despite the rocky conversation, Kris revealed that her pals at the time told her to "have a bottle of wine and go have great sex."
Thanks to their advice, it didn't take long for Kendall and Kylie Jenner to join the family!
I Am Cait airs Sundays at 9 p.m. on E!