Shirtless Michael Strahan Spotted On Vacation With Criminal Girlfriend

The 44-year-old strutted his stuff on the beach in St. Barts, accompanied by bikini-clad girlfriend Kayla Quick. 

"It remains to be seen how much Michael really knows about his girlfriend's past!" a source recently told RadarOnline.com.

The Live! With Kelly and Michael star has been seen with the 27-year-old Florida resident, Kayla, on numerous occasions after calling off his engagement to Eddie Murphy's ex-wife Nicole in 2014.

Kayla was a "good girl," her high school sweetheart Justin Hundley, 28, told RadarOnline.com, but at some point she changed. "It was like a switch was flipped. Almost overnight she became this huge partier."

At age 14, Kayla was arrested for disorderly conduct after getting into a fight in her Port Charlotte, FL., hometown, according to official documents obtained by RadarOnline.com. Because it was in juvenile court, RadarOnline.com is unable to determine the outcome of the case.

However, an arrest affidavit filed by the Charlotte County Sheriff's Office in May 2005 shows Kayla was involved in a burglary and charged with grand theft. Justin and Kayla, 18 at the time, were accused of breaking into the Port Charlotte home of her then 83-year-old grandma, Margaret Cox, and stealing about $6,000 worth of jewelry.

Margaret discovered the shocking theft after coming home where she was recuperating from an illness. She told police she wanted to press charges after a next-door neighbor witnessed Kayla and Justin hanging out inside the home. The next day Kayla called police and confessed her crime. Though it was categorized as a felony, Kayla's deed was turned over to juvenile authorities once again and RadarOnline.com is unable to determine the case's outcome.