The Situation Takes The Cake On Jersey Shore – Or Did He?

Feb. 16 2012, Published 10:00 a.m. ET

The Situation’s feud with Snooki -- centered around his allegation she cheated on her boyfriend, Jionni -- continued to build on Thursday’s Jersey Shore. And it was all triggered by a piece of cake.

After a piece of the cake Snooki and Deena Cortese baked for their boss Danny had mysteriously disappeared -- and the girls deduced that the selfish Sitch was the most likely perpetrator, based on the timelines involved -- the defensive Situation, already conscious of the fact he’s unlikely to be voted most popular anytime soon, denied any wrongdoing.

Article continues below advertisement

“I’m the unanimous decision who ate the cake ... I’m actually guilty in this house until proven innocent,” The Situation said. “I’m actually guilty in this house until proven innocent.”

The Situation's pleas of innocence tuned out to be true, as Pauly D later copped to eating the piece. After ignoring Deena’s heartfelt apology, The Situation said, “I get blamed for everything. I’ve been good the whole time.

Article continues below advertisement

Watch the video on RadarOnline.com

“I feel like the mean Mike is about to come out and you’re not going to like it,” he said, plotting on how he was going to exact revenge on Snooki with the help of his right-hand man, The Unit.

But since The Unit -- who clashed with Snooki in a previous episode -- was out of town, The Sitch said, “The master plan was derailed for another night.”

Other plot developments Thursday: J-WOWW tried to appease her boyfriend Roger with a sexy outfit after they had a fight, though Roger’s insecurity was apparent when guys were checking out his girlfriend, at the club, in the revealing attire.