Your tip

EXCLUSIVE: Dad of ‘Too Fat’ American Idol Super Fan: She Wants A Live Apology

//american idol iphone

Apr. 11 2011, Published 6:55 a.m. ET

Link to FacebookShare to XShare to Email

The teenager who claims to have been relegated to the back row at a filming of American Idol last week because she was “too big, too heavy” wants a public apology from people at the hit reality show, her father tells exclusively.

“I would like to see American Idol give her an open apology,” said Randy Kauffman. “She wants an apology and it should be a live apology, if that’s what it takes.”

Article continues below advertisement

EXCLUSIVE: Too Fat For Idol?!? Audience Member Banished To Back Seat For Being 'Too Heavy'

19-year-old Ashley Kauffman of Riverside, Calif., claimed in an exclusive interview with last week that she and five of her girlfriends got free tickets to attend the filming, but while three of her friends nabbed front row seats, she was allegedly told, “Oh no, you're just too big, too heavy to be in front!” and then by a second staffer “this makes sense why you're not with the skinny girls. You're in the last row.”

“She called me crying and saying ‘I can’t believe I didn’t get to sit with my friends.’ I told her to try to make the best of the rest of the evening, but I thought about it and told her to get it on the website…they can’t do that to you,” said Randy.

American Idol's Shocking Cast-Off Pia Toscana Lands Record Deal

Ashley ended up taking to a local Los Angeles news webpage last Friday that had posted an article about newly-eliminated Pia Toscano, as a means to vent her feelings.

Article continues below advertisement

She wrote in the comments section: "So everyone is so shocked about pia going home, as was i, but my biggest shocker with idol last night was when I wasn't allowed to sit in the front row with my friends lastnight sic because I'm too heavy! Yup I was told I couldn't sit with them because I am a little heavier than they are. I'm truly hurt and disappointed in idol!"

EXCLUSIVE: Could Voting Glitch Have Caused 'American Idol' Pia Toscano's Early Demise?


Furthermore, her dad comes to his daughter’s defense, telling that her weight gain is due to medical issues -- and not because she’s an “outrageous eater.”

“At 14, she gained weight because she had medical problems. They put her on medicine and it caused her to gain weight…she’s not obese.”

Her dad said Ashley had exploratory surgery for possible endometriosis, which was never diagnosed.

Article continues below advertisement

“They tried her on medicine and ended up doing surgery and eliminating the problem,” he said.

VIDEO & PHOTOS: American Idol Shocker! Pia Toscano Voted Off -- Crowd Boos, Judges Stunned

And, this form of “bullying” brings back memories, Randy claimed.

“She got teased in school. What Idol did is like bullying…she’s been through a lot.

VIDEO: Ralph Macchio Jokes About One-Upping Kirstie Alley's Fall

“It’s been two years since she had a soda and she’s not an outrageous eater. And you can’t judge people by the way they look.

“She’s trying to work with her problem and for someone to do that is wrong. They’re sitting in the front row because she’s not Barbie.”

For now, his daughter is simply “heartbroken.”

“It bothers her, but she’s a tough girl and she’ll get over it. But she was heartbroken.”


VIDEO: All 9 American Idol Contestants Soar On Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame NightAUDIO: L.A. Reid: ‘I’m Most Proud Of Mariah Carey... She’s Got The X-Factor’



Opt-out of personalized ads

© Copyright 2024 Radar Media Group LLC. RADAR and RADARONLINE are registered trademarks. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services. Offers may be subject to change without notice.