American Idol's Top 9 Trimmed To 8: Find Out Who Was Kicked Off!

One of the nine finalists on the 12th season of American Idol was sent packing Thursday, in what came as a mild surprise after Wednesday's Beatles night.

'Tis not the season to be Jolley, apparently.

PHOTO: Nicki Minaj Has Onstage Wardrobe Malfunction

A night after Nicki Minaj ripped his performance as "safe, very bland and forgettable," 22-year-old country singer Paul Jolley was eliminated on Thursday night's American Idol results show.

Nashville native Paul, who stumbled singing Eleanor Rigby Wednesday, landed in the bottom three this week along with Devin Velez and Amber Holcomb, whose inclusion irritated the judges.

Randy Jackson said he was "really shocked" Amber's ranking was so low, while Nick Minaj said, "I definitely think Amber should not be in the bottom three -- that's common sense."

For his last ditch effort, Paul sang Heart's power ballad Alone, but the judges weren't swayed to burn their save card on him.

One surprise Thursday was Lazaro Arbos' easy evening, as he was the first contestant announced as safe just a night after the judges' brutal assessments of his performance had him crying on live TV.

The remaining finalists are, in alphabetical order: Arbos, Janelle Arthur, Candice Glover, Kree Harrison, Holcomb, Angela Miller, Burnell Taylor and Velez.

Watch the video on RadarOnline.com

American Idol's 12th season continues next Wednesday on Fox at 8/7c.