VIDEO: American Idol's Casey James Surprises With His "Best Performance So Far"

Apr. 28 2010, Published 9:45 a.m. ET

Link to FacebookShare to XShare to Email

The excitement is building and the performers nerves are fraying as it gets ever closer to crowning the season nine American Idol.

Wednesday Night's Alright For Idol, Elton Benefit

Tuesday night saw the remaining six perform songs from country great Shania Twain's songbook, with mixed results, and has video highlights of the performances.

VIDEO: American Idol's Top 9 Shine With Guitars, Bagpipes, And Didgeridoos,Oh My!

Article continues below advertisement

For once Crystal Bowersox wasn't the clear front runner, giving a relatively lack lustre performance. Stepping up to the plate though was Kara's cougar favorite Casey James, giving what Randy said was, "One of the best Casey James performances ever" and Ellen judged as, "Your best performance to date." Even Simon raved that Casey gave his "best performance so far" with his take on the Shania hit, Don't.

American Idol: Double Elimination!

Siobhan Magnus also catapulted her way back into the competition with her rendition of Any Man Of Mine - all four judges raved, with Ellen providing the quip of the season so far with, "Way to pull the Shania Twain into the station." But Simon being Simon had to add that, "The end was almost like you were giving birth up there."

American Idol's Kara DioGuardi Strips Naked For Allure

Article continues below advertisement

VIDEO: Cat-Like Rihanna Rocks Out On American Idol

Pretty much guaranteeing himself a spot in the bottom three once again, and with no last minute judges' save to rescue him this time around, "Big Mike" Lynche gave a disappointing rendition of It Only Hurts When I Breathe. Though Randy, Ellen and Kara gave positive feedback, Simon hit the nail on the head, commenting, "The performance was a little bit wet. Like you were in a musical acting out the words. It was a little bit girly for you."


VIDEO:  American Idol Shocker! "Big Mike" Lynche Voted Off; Judges Save Him

Also looking likely to join the bottom three, Lee Dewyze scored mixed reviews with his take on You're Still The One. Randy, Ellen and Kara gave overall good reviews, though Kara commented that Lee was pulling some pretty weird faces throughout his performance!

But acid tongued Simon slammed Lee commenting that his performance "started rough and never got any better" going on to say that it was "awful".

Article continues below advertisement

EXCLUSIVE: Crystal Bowersox "Determined" To Win American

Past clear favorite to win the season, Crystal Bowersox gave an overall mediocre performance compared to her former appearances, singing No One Needs To Know Right Now. Simon who has raved week in and week out about Crystal said she sounded like a "coffee shop band" and that the song was "forgettable".

EXCLUSIVE: American Idol's Crystal Bowersox Was Bullied At School

Aaron Kelly fared better with his rendition of You've Got A Way - garnering rave reviews from all four judges. Simon commented "you did really well tonight." But the question remains, is it too little too late?

Well we will find out Wednesday on results night. Tune in to Fox at 8/7C or check back at for all the up to date American Idol news.



Opt-out of personalized ads

© Copyright 2023 Radar Media Group LLC. RADAR and RADARONLINE are registered trademarks. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services. Offers may be subject to change without notice.