Misunderstood Idol
Jan. 30 2009, Published 12:37 p.m. ET
Given the whole Paula Goodspeed situation, American Idol judges can be excused for their reaction to what happened Wednesday night when Louisville, Kentucky contestant Mark Mudd flunked his audition and said, as he left, "Take care and be careful."
Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell both seemed startled by what they perceived as a threat. Off-stage, producers were also alarmed.
"You don't say that to people, 'Be careful,'" Abdul snapped. "That's just not a normal thing to say."
- Aerosmith Announces Retirement From Touring After 54 Years — Band Confirms Steven Tyler's 'Full Recovery' From Vocal Injury 'Not Possible'
- Cardi B Announces She’s Pregnant With Baby No. 3...After Filing for Divorce AGAIN From Husband Offset: ‘With Every End Comes a New Beginning’
- Joe Biden Speaks Out for First Time Since Ditching 2024 Election Campaign — Praising ‘Capable and Tough’ VP Kamala Harris
But -- oops! Turns out "Be careful" is just a local going-away thing to say.
A statement from the Idol front office was apologetic.
"We now know better and look forward to visiting Louisville again someday."