VIDEO: Top 12 Women Are Hot and Cold With American Idol Judges

It was Ladies night on Tuesday as the top 12 women took on The Beatles, Heart and a bevy of Billboard chart topping songs.

Other than a few standout performances, the women failed to impress the judges, as over and over again the resounding theme from the judges was poor song choice.

PHOTOS: American Idol’s Top 24

Fan favorite Ashley Rodriguez sang Leona LewisHappy but fell short in Simon’s eyes.

“It was clumsy,” he told her. “I actually think you’re going backwards.”

EXCLUSIVE: American Idol Hopeful Crystal Bowersox On The Attack – With Spaghetti!

Paige Miles, Janelle Wheeler and Haeley Vaughn all seemed to struggle with their performances.

“Even if it was a mess, it was a hot mess,” Ellen told Vaughn after she attempted “I Want To Hold Your Hand” by the Beatles.

EXCLUSIVE: Tasered American Idol “Skiibosky” Has Long Arrest History

The best of the night included Katelyn Epperly’s rendition of another Beatles hit Oh Darlin, Lilly Scott who sang a very indie version of the Fab Four’s Fix It Right and Crystal Bowersox who channeled Alanis Morissette (Harmonica and all) with Hand In My Pocket.

VIDEO: American Idol’s 24 Semi-Finalists Get First Taste Of The Limelight

Siobhan Magnus was also a hit with the judges with her rendition of Wicked Game by Chris Isaak.

EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: American Idol Reject Has No Regrets About TV Meltdown

“You can blow!” Randy told Magnus, a glassblower from Cape Cod, MA.

blog comments powered by Disqus