Your tip

Nikki Bella Charged With Aggravated Assault After Allegedly Breaking Girl’s Nose In High School!

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Nikki Bella’s reputation preceded her — years before her fighting inside the ring made her a household name.

According to exclusive documents obtained by, the WWE star was known for her smackdowns in high school – and she was charged with aggravated assault for allegedly breaking a girl’s nose!

John Cena’s ex-fiancee, whose real name is Stephanie Nicole Garcia, is identified as the defendant in a 2002 case filed in Scottsdale, Arizona, after Sarah Aguirre accused the then-17-year-old of injuring her in a fight on Oct. 26, 2001 following a high school football game.

Article continues below advertisement

To make the legal mess worse for the rising star, there was a warrant motion filed for her arrest when she moved from Arizona to San Diego, California to attend college.


The warrant was later rescinded.

According to police records, the alleged victim claimed she was attacked after a football game between her high school, Saguaro, and rival school, Chaparral, where the Bella Twins attended.

She told police she was celebrating her school’s victory yelling taunts like “go home and cry” and was mobbed by rival high school girls after the game.

“Four girls walked up to her. The first of four girls pushed into her with her chest… and kicked her in the face while on the ground,” noted the police report.

When they fled in their car after a crowd started to gather, per the report, one of the girls said, “now look at who’s crying – b***h.”

Article continues below advertisement

Sarah went to the hospital as a result of her alleged injury where Scottsdale cops took her statement, which also names Brianna Garcia (aka Brie Bella) as one of the attackers.

During the investigation, police spoke to the resource officer at the reality star's high school who told cops “he received information that ‘the Garcia twins’ beat up some Saguaro girl after the Friday night football game.”

Police notes indicated the school’s assistant principal heard the same rumor involving the identical twins after the game.

Nikki Bella
Article continues below advertisement

When questioned, “Brianna told police she knew nothing of any fight,” according to the report. She said they “left early to go to McDonalds.”

Police said Stephanie recalled “the same thing,” and “they did not see or hear any fighting or yelling.”

Stephanie had no comment about the alleged incident, but admitted “she fought some Saguaro girl at a weekend party earlier in the year. Maybe they don’t like me for that.”

Article continues below advertisement

Police noted that other Chaparral students’ comments when questioned “appeared rehearsed.”

According to the report, the alleged victim’s boyfriend identified Stephanie Garcia as the initial suspect by looking at a yearbook photo.

However, the girl who claimed she was injured in the fight could not be “absolutely sure” who attacked her, but police noted she “hesitated at Stephanie’s picture.”

Stephanie, now 34, pleaded not guilty and the case was dismissed in 2003.

John Cena’s former girlfriend of six years, who broke up just weeks before their wedding, may have gotten off scot-free in court, but not with her fans who are calling the split a ratings stunt.

As reported by, things were staged from the starting bell – when Cena got down on one knee and begged the wrestling beauty to say “I do” before a massive TV audience during Wrestlemania.

We pay for juicy info! Do you have a story for Email us at, or call us at (866) ON-RADAR (667-2327) any time, day or night.



More From Radar Online

    Opt-out of personalized ads

    © Copyright 2024 RADAR ONLINE™️. A DIVISION OF MYSTIFY ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK INC. RADAR ONLINE is a registered trademark. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and Cookies Policy. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services. Offers may be subject to change without notice.