Cassie Randolph

After he says he was spotted at a gay spa last year, Underwood was forced to face reality.

Cassie was reportedly "not aware" Colton would telling all on "Good Morning America."

"There's a lot of layers to it," says the 25-year-old former reality star.

Growing up Catholic played a huge role in how he felt about himself and his sexuality.

Underwood dumped Adams to date Randolph in shock turn of events.