Brooklyn resident Devin Riley told Good Morning America that he saw the 20-year-old jogging around the neighborhood at around 9:00p.m. on July 18, like she did on most days.
“She was wearing like a neon pink sports bra with black khaki yoga pants and an armband with her music device, or phone ... hair in a ponytail, just jogging like normal, any other day,” Riley said, adding that he chose to notify authorities after he saw the girl on TV and realized it was the jogger.
"I wish I did know more, but I dread that maybe I was the last person to see her," Riley said. "I remembered seeing her that night. I just felt very weird. Who knows when she was taken in that timeline, but I don't know what happened.”
Riley also allowed investigators to do a walk-through of his home while his family was inside. Though it was a quick check-up, he said the experience was “terrifying.”
As RadarOnline.com previously reported, Tibbetts went missing three weeks ago after going for a nighttime jog around her boyfriend’s neighborhood. Investigators are working hard to find her, and her family is staying hopeful.
Her cash reward is now set at $260,000.
"It's gut-wrenching to know that I could have my daughter out here, and I could go inside for a minute and she could be gone," Riley said. "You assume when you move to a small town that pretty much everyone is close close-knit, everyone knows everyone ... you just do not expect it to happen in a town like this.”.
We pay for juicy info! Do you have a story for RadarOnline.com? Email us at firstname.lastname@example.org, or call us at 800-344-9598 any time, day or night.
For the biggest celebrity news stories of the day, controversies, crime, and other hot topics listen to our new podcast ‘All Rise’ below!