Oscar Pistorius Guilty Of At Least Culpable Homicide, According To Legal Commentator Beth Karas
![//oscar pistorius guilty of at least culpable homicide pp](https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/480x251/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 480w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/640x335/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 640w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/768x402/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 768w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/1024x536/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 1024w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/1280x670/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 1280w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/1440x753/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 1440w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/1600x837/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 1600w, https://media.radaronline.com/brand-img/gRiyT8SnB/2160x1130/2014/04/oscar-pistorius-guilty-of-at-least-culpable-homicide-pp.jpg?position=top 2160w)
Apr. 10 2014, Published 5:53 p.m. ET
As Oscar Pistorius continues to testify in his own defense in the murder trial in the death of girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp, respected legal commentator Beth Karas said she believes, based on his testimony and evidence presented to the judge, that the paralympian is guilty of at least involuntary manslaughter.
Wild About Trial's Beth Karas, says the key for Pistorius is to convince Judge Thokozile Masipa that "he believed Steenkamp was in bed when he grabbed his gun" and "that the screams the neighbors heard were not Steenkamp’s but, rather, his own upon discovering he had shot her."
(That, of course, begs the question why didn’t he call out to her -- even in a whisper -- as he armed himself; in his testimony, Pistorius said that she spoke to him from the bed when he first arose to close the balcony door, and that the critical fact was omitted from his bail application affidavit.)
Karas points out that even if Masipa finds Pistorius didn't premeditate the alleged murder, "She can consider a lesser charge called culpable homicide, which is akin to manslaughter based on a negligence theory.
- A Teen Girl Demanded Her Boyfriend Kill His Mom for Disapproving of Their Relationship, Then She Did It Herself
- 'Random Act of Violence' at Ohio Grocery Store Leaves 3-Year-Old Boy Fatally Stabbed, Mother Injured: Police
- Tulsi Gabbard’s Aunt Stabbed to Death, Beaten With Hammer as Famed Author Protege is Charged With Murder
"In other words, the judge will assess the reasonableness of Pistorius’s conduct in shooting four times through a door when he was not facing an imminent threat of death."
If convicted of murder, Pistorius faces up to 25 years in prison, and the lesser charge of culpable homicide is 15 years behind bars, but also carries a non-incarceration sentence.
"Based on the evidence, thus far, it seems the verdict will be at least guilty of culpable homicide," Karas said.