Uppereast, I think you are missing the point. OK let me get this right. You say Taylor wasn't dating Caroline. Well, after he was caught with the so called hooker what do you think he did put on a search to find a women who looked like her and just happened to find one who looked so much like her that it took an expert to carefully measure their faces to tell them apart. I'm sorry but that doesn't sound plausible or even reasonable because no one cares whether he was with a hooker or not.
Heck we see worse things on reality TV all the time.

I really don't understand what all the fuss is about. If indeed they are two different women then he certainly has dated two women who look enough alike to be twins. Hmmm in fact, that might make a better story. Taylor Hicks dates twins.
If indeed the first one was a high paid escort, I guess it was convenient that he happened to know a nice girl who was a dead ringer for the escort to do a cover up. Now the only question remaining is WHY would he bother to do this when stars are linked with Play Boy Bunnies, Hookers, gay partners, Drug dealers, wild parties, run- ins with the law, tax evasion and all kinds of unsavory activities and it does nothing but make them more popular. I wouldn't care if she was and escort. Infact, I'd be looking to find out where the service was and sign up to be his next escort. LOL