BEST: Nina Dobrev. Nina, Nina, Nina. I’m wondering if we can still be friends now that you’ve worn that dress before me. Just kiddin! Maybe. That beaded dress fits you immaculately, showing off your beautifully curvaceous body and perfect collar bone. Matched with those shoes, you are perfection.

BEST: Nina Dobrev

WORST: India Eisley. India, girl, take some risks!  You played it safe tonight and your look suffered because of it. With your light skin, you need a bold color that will pop not blend. Also, accessorize, accessorize, accessorize! It’s no wonder you’re living The Secret Life of the American Teenager. You’re a beautiful girl that can easily demand the attention of the room. Dress the part with confidence!

WORST: India Eisley.

BEST: Sarah Hyland. Look at this Modern girl! Her burst of cobalt blue is classy but also light, flirty and fun. I’m loving her use of accessories in that bracelet. Sarah, give me and call and tell me where I can find sky high black heels. Heart em and you!

BEST: Lea Michele. I can’t say this enough: fashion is about exploration. And Lea is a modern day Christopher Columbus! She understand glitz and color well, and she owns every outfit she wears. You can’t help but watch her it that gorgeous emerald green, and all of us Gleeks sure match the color with envy.

BEST: Selena Gomez. She may have an association with kid-friendly Disney, but Selena looks like a grown-up gal this evening. And a classtastic one at that! I adore this white slit-sleeved dress. And those Sergio Rossi sandals added the perfect finishing edge to her BCBG Max Azaria dress.

BEST: Selena Gomez.

BEST: Selena Gomez.

BEST: Selena Gomez.

WORST: Emma Roberts. The dress is cute, but not on Emma. She gets totally washed out by the lime green. And while that dark eye shadow can look sleek, with her pale skin it just reads sick. Love the idea behind the large rings, but I don’t like the boots. The whole outfit seems disjointed.

WORST: Emma Roberts.

BEST: Nina Dobrev

WORST: Joshua Jackson. What happened here, Joshua? I feel like you’re playing mind games with us… Are you dressing up or down? First you love us with the darling blazer and zip striped tie, than you don’t with the dark skinny denim don’ts. Shoulda listened to Katy Perry more closely.. if “you’re up, then you’re down, you’re in, then you’re out.”

BEST: Lea Michele.

WORST: Ariel Winter. Looking at Ariel tonight you’d never guess that she’s attending the The Teen Choice Awards. The dress is “cute” but not for a party like this. Her watch and necklace need to have a little more chutzpah! They’re muted and get lost in the humdrum of the dress. And those boots were made for walking to the Worst Dressed end of Mai list.