3. Fantasia Barrino has had huge success since beating Diana DeGarmo and Jennifer Hudson for the show’s third season crown in 2004, making her mark on both the charts and on Broadway, where she was cast in The Color Purple musical. She’s released two hot-selling albums which have garnered her eight Grammy nominations. She even starred in a Lifetime movie about her own life. Her third album is slated to hit shelves summer 2010. 5. Taylor Hicks went from obscurity to fame and back again: the grey-haired crooner won the fifth season crown on American Idol, but could not maintain his momentum in the music business to move onto bigger and better things. He’s currently making ends meet performing in a touring production of Grease, playing the role of Teen Angel.