It was the best of times and the worst of times — in terms of performances — on Wednesday’s edition of American Idol, as the six finalists took the stage to perform two songs — one written by iconic songwriters Burt Bacharach and Hal David, the other a song they wish they had penned.
SPOILER: Who Was The Best? Who Was The Worst?
Candice Glover emerged as the favorite among the final six, belting out a rich rendition of The Cure’s Love Song that Randy Jackson called “one of the greatest performances in the history of 12 years of American Idol.”
The praise didn’t stop there: Keith Urban raved, “It was crazy — it was one of those moments when all the stars line up, and I agree with Randy that is one of the best performances in American Idol history!”
On the other end of things, Lazaro Arbos — the only boy left in the competition — again stunk it up, as the 21-year-old had the judges shaking their heads at the lack of fundamentals shown in his rendition of The Carpenters’ Close To You.
Randy told him, “I am kind of speechless — you know I love you the person, you are an amazing guy, your story inspires us all but all I can say is, ‘No, no, no.’
“That was horrible: That was the worst performance you have ever had on the show!” the music industry vet said, later agreeing with Keith’s assessment that the competition is a “girls’ race” at this point.
Mariah Carey reminded Lazaro, “At this stage in the competition, there can’t be a key change and you stay in the old key — that is the end of the song.”
Nicki Minaj didn’t even give Lazaro a review, telling the Naples, Fla. native, “Let’s pretend I gave you my comment, because honey child, we will be here till tomorrow!”
Watch the video on RadarOnline.com
American Idol‘s 12th season continues Thursday on Fox at 8/7c.