|
< BACK TO Fresh Intelligence The Top 10 Smoking In New York Movies
SMOKE SCREEN Holly Golightly In full-page advertisements that ran in the New York Times and Wall Street Journal Tuesday, Daines said that films showing tobacco use should be rated "R" unless they show the dangers of tobacco use or depict the smoking habit of a historical figure. According to the commish, "Exposure to smoking in movies is the single most powerful pro-tobacco influence on children today, accounting for the recruitment of half of all new adolescent smokers." The good doctor wants anti-smoking ads to run before every film that shows tobacco use and called for studios to state in the closing credits that any people shown smoking in a film weren't paid to promote tobacco products. The health department reportedly shelled out $800,000 for the ads, which would buy a lot of smokes, even in Manhattan. But what is celluloid New York without cigarettes? As a public service, Radar proudly presents the Top 10 Smoking in New York Movies you might have missed had the movie gestapo jumped into the fray sooner. 1. Breakfast at Tiffany's 2. Mean Streets, Taxi Driver, and Goodfellas 3. Manhattan and Annie Hall 4. All About Eve 5. The French Connection 6. The Last Seduction 7. Midnight Cowboy 8. The Royal Tenenbaums 9. Smoke 10. The Sweet Smell of Success
#6: uh, linda fiorentino? Posted by: blondeambition on February 21, 2008 4:18 PM Our fault. We all got drunk at lunch today! Posted by: Balk on February 21, 2008 4:29 PM Six of the seven movies you named were rated "R" by the MPAA, so they wouldn't have been affected even if the R-rating for tobacco imagery applied retroactively, which it doesn't. As for nostalgia, Bette Davis and half the top stars in Hollywood (not counting Shirley Temple) had advertising contracts with tobacco companies brokered by their studios. Good examples of tobacco product placement are American Tobacco's Bull Durham roll-your-owns in The Maltese Falcon and American Tobacco's Lucky Strike in The Clock (1945). After tobacco commercials were axed in 1970, the tobacco companies went back to Hollywood and systematically jacked up smoking on screen while it was declining in real life. Cleverly done? You bet. Hollywood filmmakers are used to working around commercial demands. But does it really make a better picture? You can't know that until you see what movies are like without tobacco companies calling the shots. If the Health Commissioner, national health groups and and the World Health Organization finally succeed in splitting these twins, we'll all have a chance to find out. Posted by: jpolansky on February 21, 2008 5:19 PM Correx: 9 out of 12 of these dilms with smoking were rated "R," actually. Two of the others weren't originally rated by the MPAA (whose system debuted in 1964) and Annie Hall was PG. Posted by: jpolansky on February 21, 2008 5:24 PM Advertisement After Hours is a stretch. I believe Dunne has two smokes at most in the whole movie. Taxi Driver? Not a lot of smoking in that one either. Good Fellas, hell yeah. When DeNiro is sucking down that smoke in the bar eying that annoying guy who keeps asking for his cash...best ad for smoking since the Marloboro Man. Pope of Greenwich Village--one of the best smoking movies ever. Posted by: Chinanski on February 22, 2008 8:01 AM |
![]() |
|
||