left arrow BackNext right arrow
< BACK TO Fresh Intelligence

Hillary's Planting Problem Redux

hillary_010408_fresh.jpg
STAY IN SCHOOL Hillary (Photo: Getty Images)
Still smarting from her third-place finish in Iowa, Hillary Clinton heads into New Hampshire having learned a valuable lesson: don't try to strong-arm a college kid.

Slate's Trailhead blog notes that a misstep in one undergrad-heavy district just may have cost Clinton the delegates she needed to procure that second-place tie with John Edwards. Writes Christopher Beam: "In the Grinnell Ward 1 caucus I attended, Hillary had 44 supporters. She needed 73 to be reach the 15 percent viability threshold. Had she been viable, she would have received at least six of the precinct's 37 delegates. In other words, had 30 more Grinnell residents turned out for Hillary and 30 less for Edwards, she would have tied John Edwards for second in the state."

Grinnell is, of course, home to Grinnell College, an academic institution Clinton never bothered to visit (she was the only major Democratic candidate not to do so). Her decision to skip the campus wasn't exactly arbitrary: Clinton was busted last November for using a Grinnell student as an audience "plant" during an energy speech in Newton, Iowa.

The student, a sophomore, had wanted to ask Hillary how her energy plan compared to the other candidates. She was instead instructed by a Clinton staffer to ask, "As a young person, I'm worried about the long-term effects of global warming. How does your plan combat climate change?" She obliged so as to "be agreeable," but word of the incident got out after it was reported in a school paper. Needless to say, it certainly buttressed the New York senator's reputation as someone who is so calculating as to seem inauthentic. Which some might say is why she finished third in the first place.

As Beam notes, it's not hard to imagine that Clinton could have swung at least 30 impressionable young voters with a single visit. For the record, her staff claimed that the Grinnell incident was an isolated one and that no further plants would be used in the future, despite the fact that a handful of "I was told to ask this!" stories surfaced in its aftermath.

Comments

Be the first to respond. Post your comment below.

Advertisement


Post a comment

Your comment will not be visible for about a minute. If you don't see your comment when the page reloads, do not post it again. Reload the page in a minute, and you'll see it.

 


Stormy Handsy Sober Weekend Ahead!

Bear Busts Pot Farm

RNC Convention: The Final Chapter

Manhunting For Public Health

David Cho Introduces You To The Seductive Arts Of The Donk

America Hoping Condi's Sex Appeal Will Make Gaddafi Forget All About That Lockerbie Stuff

Yigal Azrouel Overrun by Youth, Andre Leon Talley

When Politicians Make Bad Choices

Fashion Week Begins

'NYT' Shrinks Radically


EXECUTIVE EDITOR:


MANAGING EDITOR:


EDITOR AT LARGE:


STAFF WRITER:


CONTRIBUTORS:



and others



Email us at:
tips@radaronline.com
or IM: TipRadar







The Vice Storm
America's scandalous weathermen

Making Number Two
A brief history of disastrous vice presidential choices

Radlibs: Convention Edition
Create a magic, base-stirring moment with Radar's nomination acceptance speech generator

Full Court Press
Charles Kaiser on McCain's McGovern Moment

Friends Without Benefits
For some celebrities, pals are found on the payroll





Bristol's Mom
She's got it going on

Andrea Mitchell Battles Republican Balloons
She loses

The Best Political Pundit In The Entire World
Someone give this man a show

They Don't Call Her Sarah Baracuda For Nothing
How John McCain Picked Sarah Palin

An Exclusive Preview From The Forthcoming Feature Film "Choke"
Here's A First Look At The Film Adaptation Of Chuck Palahniuk's Choke